In Articles, Artigos

When Corporate Risk Becomes Personal

Patent infringement is usually seen as a business problem, since it is generally the company that receives a cease-and-desist letter or is summoned to defend itself in a lawsuit. In the criminal sphere, however, this logic is reversed.

In patent crime cases, it is not the company that is called to answer, but potentially its partners, directors and managers. This creates a risk that, by definition, falls on those who may in some way be accused of infringing a patent.

This personal exposure is not limited to criminal proceedings. It may also have consequences in the civil sphere, since the separation between a legal entity and its partners does not, in itself, protect someone who personally takes part in an unlawful act.

A good example comes from the state of Paraná. In March 2018, the 18th Civil Chamber of the Paraná Court of Appeals (TJPR) jointly decided Civil Appeals No. 1,691,259-7 and No. 1,691,269-3. On one side were the inventor of a probiotic containing digestive enzymes, used as a growth promoter in cattle and other animals, and a company in the sector. On the other were four livestock products companies and their partners, accused of exploiting the patented formula without authorization.

The court rejected the claim that the patent was invalid and, based on the expert examination, upheld the judgment against three of the companies. The fourth escaped liability because it was already exploiting the product in good faith before the patent application was filed, a situation covered by Article 45 of Brazil’s Industrial Property Law (Law No. 9,279/1996). As for the partners, the court refused to hold them liable merely because they represented the companies and limited the judgment to the only partner who had personally acted unlawfully. That partner was held liable for material damages and was also ordered to pay BRL 30,000 to the inventor for moral (non-pecuniary) damages.

Officers may therefore be held personally liable in both spheres: in the criminal sphere, when they act with intent, and in the civil sphere, even for negligence. Understanding when this happens and, above all, how to avoid it should be part of managing legal risk in intellectual property.

Civil liability of company officers

Article 42 of the Industrial Property Law grants the patent holder the right to prevent third parties from producing, using, offering for sale, selling or importing the protected subject matter without its consent. If a company exploits the patent without authorization, the lawsuit is brought against the company. In some circumstances, however, the individual who made the decision may, in principle, also be held liable.

Article 158 of the Brazilian Corporations Law (Law No. 6,404/1976) is clear: an officer is not liable for obligations undertaken on behalf of the company in the regular course of management, but is liable for losses caused when acting with fault (culpa) or intent (dolo), or in breach of the law or the bylaws. For limited liability companies (sociedades limitadas), Article 1,016 of the Brazilian Civil Code provides that officers are jointly and severally liable to the company and to injured third parties for fault in the performance of their duties.

Fault, in this context, may even include negligence, for example when a manager fails to use reasonable means to verify freedom to operate (FTO). This may be seen as a lack of the diligence expected of an officer, depending on other criteria that may vary from case to case.

Such an oversight, so to speak, may involve substantial amounts, since loss of profits is calculated using the criterion most favorable to the injured party, which may be, for example, the benefit obtained by the infringer itself (Article 210 of the Industrial Property Law).

The risk also materializes within the company itself: in certain cases, the company and its shareholders, for example, may seek compensation from the officer for the losses he or she caused to the company (Article 159 of the Brazilian Corporations Law).

In the criminal sphere, however, liability goes far beyond the financial aspect

The Industrial Property Law defines as crimes manufacturing a patented product and using a patented means or process (Article 183). Selling, offering for sale, keeping in stock or importing products manufactured in infringement of a patent, among other conduct, is also a crime (Article 184). Since a legal entity cannot be the perpetrator of these crimes, the criminal complaint is directed at the individuals who took part in the infringement, which therefore includes managers.

Although the penalties for these crimes generally do not lead to imprisonment, the effects of criminal proceedings on the life of the accused are well known. In the business environment, this may mean a serious management crisis, institutional instability, loss of credibility and, ultimately, the risk of an actual conviction.

Great caution is also needed when exploiting technologies that, at first glance, do not appear to infringe a patent because certain modifications have been made. Article 186 of the Industrial Property Law provides that “the crimes in this Chapter are characterized even if the infringement does not affect all the claims of the patent or is restricted to the use of means equivalent to the subject matter of the patent” (free translation).

That said, it is important to note that the criminal route is more demanding.

In civil matters, proving fault is, in principle, sufficient. In criminal matters, however, intent is required: the accused must have willfully engaged in the conduct or accepted the risk of the result. Because patent crimes are subject to private criminal prosecution (Article 199 of the Industrial Property Law), meaning that proceedings depend on a complaint filed by the patent holder rather than by the public prosecutor, it is up to the holder to demonstrate these elements in the criminal complaint (queixa-crime) itself.

Time limits are another aspect that highlights the specific nature of the criminal sphere, as they are shorter than in civil proceedings. The criminal complaint, for example, must be filed within six months from the day the patent holder learns who committed the crime (Article 38 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). If there has been a search and seizure, the deadline is 30 days from the court’s approval of the expert report (Article 529 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).

In addition, given the need to describe the criminal conduct of the accused, the complaint must sufficiently detail what each defendant did. Merely pointing to someone’s status as a partner is not enough to establish criminal liability.

By way of example, the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) reinforced this point in 2023, in Special Appeal (REsp) No. 1,931,069/SP, holding that “it is not admissible to include someone as a defendant in criminal proceedings solely because of their status as a partner or the position held in the organization, without indicating any other factual element showing the causal link between the defendant’s conduct and the criminal act, even in the case of a crime of collective authorship allegedly committed through the use of a legal entity” (free translation).

These particularities of the criminal sphere may explain why convictions for patent infringement are rare in case law. Even so, the risk is not negligible: beyond the risk of conviction, criminal proceedings affect the manager personally, with a direct impact on his or her reputation and that of the company.

When corporate risk becomes personal

None of the situations below proves, on its own, infringement or intent. Depending on the circumstances, however, they may indicate that the manager knew about the infringement or failed to act with the expected diligence:

  • Ignoring notices: continuing production or sales after being notified by the patent holder, without any technical analysis or response.
  • Disregarding warnings: going ahead with a launch without considering an opinion that points to a concrete risk of infringement.
  • Knowingly reproducing the protected solution: ordering the manufacture or sale of a product covered by a patent in force, while aware of the infringement.
  • Making merely cosmetic adjustments: changing secondary details while knowing that the solution is still covered by the patent, including by equivalence.

Reverse engineering, in isolation, does not constitute infringement. What matters is the solution actually exploited and the scope of the claims. The law also exempts acts carried out for experimental purposes in connection with scientific or technological studies or research (Article 43, II, of the Industrial Property Law).

D&O insurance and indemnity agreements: protection with limits

Many managers rely on D&O (Directors and Officers) insurance, which covers the civil liability of officers under the terms of the policy. This coverage has limits. In REsp No. 1,601,555/SP, decided in 2017 in an insider trading case, the STJ held that D&O insurance does not cover intentional acts by the officer. Law No. 15,040/2024 (Brazil’s new Insurance Contract Law, known as Marco Legal dos Seguros), in force since December 11, 2025, went further and declared null and void any coverage for the risk of intentional acts by the insured party itself (Article 10, sole paragraph, II).

Indemnity agreements, under which the company undertakes to bear certain expenses of the manager, follow the same logic. For publicly held companies, Guidance Opinion No. 38/2018 of the Brazilian Securities and Exchange Commission (CVM) recommends excluding from coverage acts committed in bad faith, with intent, with gross negligence or through fraud.

This does not mean that an accusation or a lawsuit eliminates all protection. Under the terms of each policy and contract, defense costs may be advanced and later reimbursed if the exclusion is confirmed, which depends precisely on the diligence with which the manager acted.

How managers can protect themselves

Informed, diligent and good-faith decisions weigh in the officer’s favor. In the liability action provided for in Article 159 of the Brazilian Corporations Law, paragraph 6 allows the court to exclude the liability of an officer who acted in good faith and in the company’s interest. This provision, however, does not prevent an action by a directly injured third party, such as the patent holder (paragraph 7).

A recent European precedent shows the weight of such diligence. On October 3, 2025, in Philips v. Belkin, the Court of Appeal of the Unified Patent Court (UPC) upheld the finding of infringement against the companies. It nevertheless set aside the injunction and the damages claim against their directors. According to the court, holding a position does not, in itself, give rise to personal liability. Conduct going beyond typical management duties is required, such as deliberately using the company to infringe or, being aware of the infringement, failing to stop it.

The UPC also accepted that a director may, as a rule, rely on a well-founded legal opinion concluding that there is no infringement, until a first-instance decision holds otherwise.

This does not make a legal opinion an automatic safe harbor, but it helps explain why specialized, documented analysis makes a difference. Some measures can reduce risk and demonstrate precisely the diligence that may be expected:

  • Prior art search: survey the state of the art related to the product or process. The search serves two purposes. During development, it indicates whether the solution is already protected by third parties or has fallen into the public domain. When a third-party patent is identified, it gathers documents predating the filing that may support its invalidation for lack of novelty or inventive step.
  • Freedom to operate (FTO) analysis: based on that search, verify before launch whether there are patents in force whose claims cover the product or process, with the support of lawyers and registered industrial property agents. The analysis is territorial and time-specific, and must be redone whenever the product changes or new patents emerge in the segment.
  • Design-around: when the FTO analysis points to a risk, redesign the product or process so that it no longer falls within the patent claims. The redesign must be genuine, not merely cosmetic, or it may constitute infringement by equivalence (Article 186 of the Industrial Property Law). Ideally, the alternative solution should be validated by a technical opinion before it reaches the market.
  • R&D team training: train engineers, technicians and product managers to recognize when a solution may be protected, to search patent databases and to raise questions with the legal department before adopting solutions inspired by competitors’ products. It is also worth providing guidance on recording development work, with dates and versions, which may be decisive in a future dispute.
  • Continuous monitoring: track competitors’ patents and applications through competitive intelligence in IP. Once a patent is granted, Article 44 of the Industrial Property Law guarantees compensation also for prior exploitation, as a rule from the publication of the application, a topic covered in our article on delays in patent granting.
  • Record of prior use: document, with dates, the development and exploitation of solutions created in-house. Article 45 of the Industrial Property Law guarantees anyone who was already exploiting the subject matter in good faith in Brazil, before the patent application was filed, the right to continue doing so. This was the defense that cleared one of the companies in the case decided by the TJPR.
  • Technical response and record of decisions: submit every notice to specialized analysis and document launch decisions in risk areas, with their technical and legal grounds.
  • License or patent challenge: negotiate a license with the patent holder or, where there are grounds, challenge the patent before the INPI, Brazil’s Patent and Trademark Office, within six months of grant (Article 51 of the Industrial Property Law), or in court while it remains in force (Article 56).
  • Supplier clauses: require non-infringement warranties and indemnification clauses, especially for imported or resold products. These clauses govern reimbursement between the parties but do not prevent action by the patent holder.

Third-party patents are a governance issue

Patent infringement is a matter of corporate governance involving the legal department, R&D and those who set the direction of the business. The same reasoning applies to trademarks and industrial designs, which also have their own criminal offenses under the Industrial Property Law.

Ultimately, what determines personal liability is the officer’s conduct. In civil matters, fault may suffice; in criminal matters, however, patent crimes require intent. In both cases, informed and documented decisions are the best defense.

The team at Ricci Intellectual Property has more than three decades of experience in patent protection and industrial property disputes and can help companies operating or planning to operate in Brazil innovate with confidence.

Autor

Contact

Welcome! Please write your message here and we will contact you shortly. Thank you!

Start typing and press Enter to search